Taxpayer Dollars MISSING — Hochul Under Fire

Man pointing at Investigate magnifying glass icon

New York Governor Kathy Hochul faces a serious federal investigation for allegedly hoarding over $1 billion in Medicaid funds to cover state budget deficits while forcing local governments to increase taxes and cut essential services.

Key Takeaways

  • House Republicans launched an investigation into Governor Hochul for allegedly withholding federal Medicaid funding to address New York’s budget shortfall.
  • The alleged scheme has reportedly forced local governments to raise property taxes and cut services, particularly impacting small and mid-sized counties.
  • Nassau University Medical Center sued the state for being denied $1.06 billion in federal Medicaid funding, claiming this practice has continued for over two decades.
  • The House Oversight Committee, led by Chairman James Comer and subcommittee Chair Marjorie Taylor Greene, has requested records from Hochul’s office with a July 16 deadline.
  • Hochul’s administration began phasing out federal funding for Medicaid services to localities in May 2023, with plans to end it completely by April 2026.

Billion-Dollar Medicaid Misappropriation Investigation

The House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform has launched a formal investigation into New York Governor Kathy Hochul’s administration following allegations of massive misappropriation of federal Medicaid funds. Led by Committee Chairman James Comer, DOGE Subcommittee Chairwoman Marjorie Taylor Greene, and New York GOP Representatives Mike Lawler and Nick Langworthy, the investigation centers on reports that New York State has been withholding and clawing back Medicaid funds intended for localities and low-income hospitals to instead cover state budget shortfalls.

“This fiscal coverup has forced local governments to increase property taxes and cut local services,” Republican lawmakers stated in their official communication to the governor’s office.

The investigation follows Hochul’s 2023 budget plan that resulted in withholding over $1 billion in federal Medicaid funds from localities. Beginning in May 2023, her administration started phasing out federal funding for Medicaid services to localities with plans to eliminate it entirely by April 2026. This shift in funding responsibility has reportedly created severe financial strain on local governments, particularly in smaller counties that lack the tax base to absorb such costs.

Local Impacts and Hospital Takeover

The alleged misappropriation has had devastating effects on local communities and healthcare systems throughout New York State. Counties like Broome and Erie have reportedly been forced to increase property taxes and cut vital services to make up for the funding gap. The situation reached a breaking point in Nassau County, where funding issues led to what local officials describe as a “hostile takeover” of Nassau University Medical Center’s board by the governor, prompting several executive resignations.

“As a 10-year veteran of Chautauqua County government, including as county executive, I can tell you that the state saddles county government with the out-of-control cost of Medicaid,” State Sen. George Borello said, highlighting the burden placed on local governments.

Nassau University Medical Center (NUMC) has sued the state for being denied $1.06 billion in federal Medicaid funding. The lawsuit claims the hospital has been forced to cover New York’s Federal Medical Assistance Percentage (FMAP) costs for over two decades. Further exacerbating the situation, Hochul’s budget deal included creating a state-run board at NUMC, effectively removing local officials from leadership positions in what critics characterize as a power grab to maintain control over the funding stream.

Federal Investigation and Potential Consequences

The House Oversight Committee has formally requested extensive records and communications from Hochul’s office related to the Medicaid funding issue, setting a deadline of July 16 for compliance. The investigation is specifically examining claims that New York State has been forcing safety net hospitals to reimburse the state’s portion of Medicaid match while simultaneously reporting to the federal government that these funds were being used by the hospitals themselves.

“The abuse of federal taxpayer funds intended to ensure health care coverage for the most vulnerable to cover up your state’s budget shortfall is unacceptable,” Rep. Mike Lawler and other lawmakers declared in their communication to the governor.

Hochul’s spokesperson has attempted to deflect the investigation, characterizing it as a political distraction by Republicans from their own healthcare policy decisions. However, the bipartisan concern over the misuse of federal funds and the detailed documentation being requested suggests this investigation may have serious implications for the governor’s administration. With Medicaid being a joint state and federal program where federal reimbursement rates range from 50% to 83% based on a state’s income, any proven misappropriation could result in significant federal penalties and required repayments.

Two-Decade Pattern of Abuse

Perhaps most concerning in the allegations is the claim that this financial scheme has been ongoing for over 20 years, involving more than $1 billion at Nassau University Medical Center alone. The systematic nature of the alleged abuse suggests a deeply entrenched pattern of financial mismanagement that spans multiple administrations but has apparently continued and potentially expanded under Hochul’s leadership.

“The Committee on Oversight and Government Reform is investigating reports that the State of New York has been failing to abide by the law and match federal Medicaid funds. According to recent reports, the State of New York has been withholding or clawing back Medicaid funds from localities and low-income hospitals in order to buoy its failing balance sheet,” the lawmakers stated in their official investigation announcement.

As President Trump’s administration continues to emphasize fiscal responsibility and proper stewardship of taxpayer dollars, this investigation represents an important step toward holding state governments accountable for the appropriate use of federal funds. The July 16 deadline for document production will be a critical next step in determining the full extent of the alleged misappropriation and what consequences may follow for New York’s leadership.

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR