Brazil’s Top Court Upholds Decision To Ban X Platform

Brazil’s highest court has upheld a decision to block Elon Musk’s social media platform X within the country.

At a Glance

A Brazilian Supreme Court panel upheld a decision to block Elon Musk’s social media platform X nationwide.
The Supreme Court cited X’s failure to name a local legal representative and outstanding fines exceeding $3 million.
Musk criticized the ruling, accusing the panel of violating the Brazilian constitution.
Users are migrating to alternative platforms like Bluesky and Threads.

Brazil Blocks Access to X

The Brazilian Supreme Court has upheld a decision to block Elon Musk’s social media platform X nationwide. The unanimous ruling by the five justices, including Justice Alexandre de Moraes, was based on X’s failure to appoint a local legal representative and to address outstanding fines totaling over $3 million.

X was ordered to be removed from app stores and blocked from devices within five days, leading to a scramble among users to migrate to alternative platforms like Bluesky and Threads. The decision has opened a conflict between Brazil and Musk’s satellite internet provider, Starlink, which is facing demands to enforce the block or risk losing its operating license.

Justice Alexandre de Moraes also imposed a daily fine for using VPNs to access X, raising questions among legal experts about the legitimacy and enforceability of such measures. Starlink initially refused to comply with the block unless its frozen assets were released, but it eventually announced it would be complying with the decision.

Brazil's supreme court has decided to unanimously uphold a decision to block Elon Musk's social media platform X.

🔗 Read more
https://t.co/M9faHTU51x

— Sky News (@SkyNews) September 3, 2024

Legal and Political Repercussions

Musk did not hesitate to vocalize his contempt for Justice de Moraes’ ruling, accusing him of violating Brazil’s constitution. On the platform itself, Musk wrote, “He violated the constitution of Brazil repeatedly and egregiously, after swearing an oath to protect it,” – words that stirred significant backlash. Despite Musk’s protest, Brazilian legal experts maintain that de Moraes’ actions, while controversial, are within the bounds of the law.

Disagreements between Musk and the Brazilian judiciary have taken an international dimension. De Moraes has asserted the sovereignty of the Brazilian judiciary should not be compromised by external powers, accusing Musk of trying to position himself above national laws.

The Future of Social Media in Brazil

While the decision to block X has significant implications for freedom of speech and access to information, it also poses substantial operational challenges for tech companies within Brazil.

The long-term impacts on Brazil’s digital landscape remain uncertain. With tens of millions of users affected, the larger question may be whether Brazil succeeds in enforcing its decisions or if Musk’s defiance sets a new precedent for tech companies worldwide.